Why websites drop in the rankings after a relaunch
Google does not rank a website; it ranks individual URLs. Every subpage has built up trust over the years: through its content, links from other sites, clicks and time on page. During a relaunch, three things almost always happen at once:
- The URLs change. /services/bathroom-renovation.html becomes /bathroom. To Google that is a new, unknown page, and the old one has vanished.
- Content gets cut. The old page had 600 words on a topic; the new one has three snappy sentences. The search terms the page used to be found for no longer appear.
- Signals get lost. Page titles, headings, internal links, image descriptions and structured data are not carried over because nobody wrote them down.
Each point on its own costs a few positions. Together they cost the visibility that ten years of work have built up. The good news: all three can be avoided with preparation.
Before the relaunch: take stock
What you have not measured, you cannot miss after the relaunch. That is why every relaunch with us starts with an inventory.
- Record every URL. A crawl of the old website, supplemented by the page list from Google Search Console and the sitemap. That includes images, PDFs and pages that are not in the navigation.
- Note the performance of each page. From Search Console: clicks, impressions, most important search terms and position over the last twelve months. This produces the list of pages that must not lose under any circumstances.
- Check external links. Which pages are linked from other websites? Business directories, partners, press, trade associations. These URLs definitely need a redirect.
- Save the technical signals. Export titles, meta descriptions, headings, structured data and alt texts. In a spreadsheet, that is done in an hour.
- Record your baseline. Load time, Core Web Vitals, number of indexed pages, position for your ten most important search terms. Without these figures you cannot tell after the launch whether anything got worse.
The most important rule
Do not change everything at once. Switching design, structure, content, technology and domain in a single step is the surest way to have no idea what went wrong when problems appear. A domain change is always a project in its own right.
The redirect map: the heart of the relaunch
Every old URL gets a new one. This table is the most important document in the entire project.
- One to one wherever possible. The old service page redirects to the new service page on the same topic. Not to the overview, not to the home page.
- Status code 301. A permanent redirect transfers the trust of the old URL to the new one. Temporary redirects (302) or JavaScript redirects do not do that reliably.
- No chains. Old redirects to new, not to an intermediate URL that redirects again. Existing redirects from earlier relaunches are updated so that they land directly on the final target.
- Pages without a successor. If there really is no suitable target, the URL answers with status code 410. That tells Google clearly that the page is gone on purpose. Redirecting everything wholesale to the home page is treated by Google as an error page.
- Do not forget images and documents. PDFs with price lists or instructions are often linked from outside and rank for search terms of their own.
- Test before launch. The complete map is checked on the staging environment before the new site goes live. Not afterwards.
Content: trim yes, lose no
Modern websites are tidier than old ones. That is good for visitors but dangerous for rankings if content you were found for disappears along the way.
- Keep each page's search terms. The terms a page earned clicks for in Search Console must appear in the heading, body text or title of the new page. Rephrasing is allowed, dropping them is not.
- Merge with care. If three old pages become one new one, the new page must cover the content of all three, and all three old URLs redirect to it.
- Carry over titles and headings. The page title is the strongest single signal. A title that works is not changed for design reasons.
- Rebuild the internal linking. Which pages link to each other? This structure shows Google what matters. The new navigation and the links within the text should reproduce it at least as well.
- Take the structured data with you. Business details, opening hours, reviews, FAQ: whatever existed as structured data on the old site belongs on the new one too.
Technology: the mistakes that happen most often
- The staging environment stays blocked. During development the new website was hidden from Google with “noindex”. At launch, somebody forgets to remove the block. The new site disappears from the index within days. This is the single most common mistake of all.
- robots.txt blocks crawling. Same principle, different place.
- The old sitemap stays online. The new sitemap is submitted in Search Console and the old one removed.
- Load time gets worse. New designs often bring large images, videos and animations with them. Measure the Core Web Vitals before and after launch. Our article on INP and Core Web Vitals explains how.
- Canonical tags point to the staging environment. A classic when moving from a staging URL.
- Tracking is missing. Analytics, Search Console and conversion tracking must be working on launch day, otherwise the data for monitoring is missing.
- Accessibility gets worse. New designs with light grey text on a white background, missing focus states or unlabelled form fields have been more than a usability problem since the BFSG (Germany's Accessibility Strengthening Act) came into force. Our BFSG quick check shows the most serious errors.
After the launch: eight weeks of monitoring
The launch is the beginning of the critical phase, not its end.
- Day 1: Check every redirect on the live site, check noindex and robots.txt, submit the new sitemap, request indexing of the most important pages in Search Console.
- Week 1: Read the Search Console coverage reports daily. Add error pages (404) to the redirect map immediately. Measure load time.
- Weeks 2 to 4: Compare the positions of your most important search terms with the baseline. Fluctuation is normal; individual pages dropping by more than ten positions point to a specific error.
- Weeks 4 to 8: The rankings should have stabilised. Now it becomes clear whether the relaunch was neutral or even brought gains. Write to external partners who link to old URLs and ask them to update their links.
If important pages are still clearly below their old level after eight weeks, the inventory from the start helps: which search terms are missing, which links are gone, which redirect is missing. There is almost always a specific cause.
A relaunch without the risk
In a relaunch with HMF-IT, the inventory, the redirect map and the eight weeks of monitoring are included in the fixed price. To find out what a relaunch costs, read our article What does a website cost in Osnabrück?. More about how we work on our web design in Osnabrück page.
Frequently asked questions about relaunches
Why does a website lose rankings after a relaunch?
Usually for three reasons: old URLs are not redirected, or redirected incorrectly; content is shortened or merged; and technical signals such as titles, headings, internal links or structured data are lost.
How long does it take Google to process a relaunch?
Some fluctuation in the first two weeks is normal. After four to eight weeks the rankings should have stabilised. If important pages are still clearly below their old level after that, there is almost always a specific error.
Do I have to redirect all of my old pages?
Every URL that had visitors or rankings, or that is linked from other websites, needs a 301 redirect to the matching new page. Pages without a successor are redirected to the closest related page or answer with a 410 — never redirected wholesale to the home page.
Can I change my domain as part of the relaunch?
Yes, but not at the same time as everything else. A domain change is a project in its own right, including a change of address in Google Search Console.
What does a relaunch that protects your rankings cost?
Inventory, redirect map and monitoring make up around 10 to 20 per cent of the project effort. For a mid-sized business website that is usually €500 to €1,500 — a small price against months of lost enquiries.
Planning a relaunch?
We will look at your existing website and tell you which pages must not lose under any circumstances. Free of charge, within 24 hours.
Discuss your relaunch